Drill vs Impact Driver: Differences, Torque and Which to Buy
Buy the drill/driver first. It drills holes of most sizes, drives screws with a clutch that stops the turn at a set torque, and takes round-shank bits directly. An impact driver is the second tool: it drives long screws and lag-type fasteners faster and with less wrist strain, but it holds only 1/4-inch hex bits and has no clutch. For general home projects that means pilot holes, shelves, furniture hardware and cabinet screws, where a drill is the better fit. For a deck, a fence, or dozens of 3-inch screws, an impact driver earns its place.
The two tools look alike and often share a battery platform, which is why they are sold as pairs. The difference is inside the housing, and it explains which jobs each one wins.
How a drill works: chuck, clutch and steady torque
A drill/driver turns its chuck continuously. Its three-jaw chuck closes around a bit shank, round or hex, within the chuck’s capacity. The kit Milwaukee sells as the M12 FUEL 3403-22, for example, has a 1/2-inch all-metal chuck and a mechanical clutch for driving fasteners. The clutch is a ring of numbered settings behind the chuck. When the screw resists more than the selected setting allows, the clutch slips and the chuck stops driving. That is how a drill seats a cabinet screw flush without burying it.
Because the turn is smooth and continuous, a drill is the precise tool. The Drive’s explainer puts it plainly: “a drill is superior when precision is of utmost importance.” It also notes that forcing a drill through hard driving bogs down the motor.
How an impact driver works: hammer, anvil and a hex collet
An impact driver has the same kind of motor, but a spring-loaded hammer and an anvil sit between the motor shaft and the bit holder. Per The Drive, “until enough load is applied, the spring forces the hammer against the anvil, which allows it to act just like a drill.” When the fastener resists, the hammer cams back, compresses the spring, and then slams forward into the anvil, which adds a burst of rotational force. Pro Tradecraft adds that most models have two hammers and two anvils, and some Metabo HPT models have three.
The holder is a quick-change collet that accepts bits with a 1/4-inch hex shank. Pulling the collet forward releases the bit and letting go locks it. A collet made for hex shanks does not grip a round shank the way a three-jaw chuck does, so drill bits for an impact driver are made with hex shanks or fitted through an adapter.
The impacts change how the tool feels and where it works. The Drive says impact drivers use motors that supply more torque than a drill, plus an impact action that helps drive fasteners through more rigid materials under load. Pro Tradecraft notes the impacting adds handle vibration, so the tool feels rougher than a drill, and that its high speed and force suit it poorly to small screws such as cabinet hardware.
There is also no clutch. An impact driver controls depth with the trigger, the speed mode, and your eyes.
Torque and impact rate as manufacturers publish them
Published numbers are the easiest thing to compare and the easiest to misread. The table below lists only figures taken from the manufacturers’ own product pages, as of November 2026. Torque is in inch-pounds (in-lbs); 12 in-lbs is 1 foot-pound.
| Tool (type) | Published max torque | No-load speed | Impacts / blows per minute | Length | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M12 FUEL 3403-22 (drill/driver) | 400 in-lbs | up to 1,550 RPM, 2 speeds | n/a | 5.9 in | 2.5 lb with battery (2.1 lb bare) |
| Makita XFD131 (drill/driver) | 440 in-lbs | 0-500 / 0-1,900 RPM | n/a | 6-5/8 in | 3.8 lb with battery |
| Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2904-20 (hammer drill) | 1,400 in-lbs | up to 2,100 RPM | not listed | 6.9 in | 3.3 lb bare |
| Makita XPH14Z (hammer drill) | 1,250 in-lbs | 0-550 / 0-2,100 RPM | 0-8,250 / 0-31,500 BPM | 7 in | 6 lb with battery |
| Milwaukee M12 FUEL 3453-20 (impact driver) | 1,500 in-lbs | up to 3,600 RPM | up to 4,000 IPM | 5 in | 2 lb with battery (1.6 lb bare) |
| Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953-20 (impact driver) | 2,000 in-lbs | up to 3,900 RPM | up to 4,400 IPM | 4.47 in | 2.2 lb bare |
| Makita XDT20Z (impact driver) | 1,590 in-lbs | 0-1,100 to 0-3,600 RPM, 4 speeds | 0-1,100 to 0-3,800 IPM | 4-1/2 in | 3.3 lb with battery |
Four points follow from the table.
An impact driver’s torque figure is not a drill’s torque figure. The two compact drill/drivers in the table are listed at 400 and 440 in-lbs, while Milwaukee’s compact impact driver is listed at 1,500. Makers define these maximums in their own way: DeWalt, for example, labels the 2,100 in-lbs on its hammer-drill page as “rated max brake torque”. A drill’s clutch also limits the torque it applies at the screw. Neither number is a calibrated tightening torque, so neither tells you how tight a fastener will end up.
Impact rate is a different quantity from speed. Makita’s XDT20Z is rated 0-3,600 RPM and 0-3,800 impacts per minute at its top setting, with lower settings at 1,100, 2,600 and 3,600 impacts. Milwaukee lists its M12 3453-20 at up to 3,600 RPM and 4,000 impacts per minute, and its M18 2953-20 at up to 3,900 RPM and 4,400. The impact rate and the torque rating do not rank the tools the same way: the Makita has the lowest impact rate of the three but a higher torque figure (1,590 in-lbs) than the M12 Milwaukee (1,500 in-lbs).
Impact drivers are compact. The M18 2953-20 is 4.47 inches long and weighs 2.2 pounds as a bare tool, and it is shorter than every drill in the table. That is the reason to own one for work between joists, inside cabinets, or overhead.
The hammer drill’s figure is a third kind of number. The Makita XPH14Z’s 0-31,500 blows per minute is more than eight times the 3,800 impacts per minute of Makita’s XDT20Z, and it counts a different motion: a hammer drill’s blows push the bit forward and back along its axis, while an impact driver’s impacts add rotation.
Hammer drill vs impact driver
A hammer drill is a drill with a second mode. In hammer mode the bit is driven forward and back while it turns, which is the action used to drill masonry. Makita’s XPH14Z page lists its hammer action at up to 31,500 blows per minute with a 1/2-inch all-metal, self-ratcheting chuck. DeWalt’s product page for its 1/2-inch XR hammer drill describes the tool as for large holes in wood, metal and concrete.
An impact driver’s strikes are rotational, as described above, so a drill’s “hammer” mode and an impact driver are different functions. Check the selector labels (drill/drive, hammer drill) before choosing a bit. When an anchor maker specifies a hole diameter, depth and cleaning procedure for concrete, those instructions override whatever the tool box suggests.
Which tool wins which job
| Job | Better tool | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Pilot and clearance holes in wood | Drill | Round-shank twist and brad-point bits go straight into the chuck |
| Large holes with a hole saw, spade or auger bit | Drill | Round and specialised shanks go in the chuck; hex-shank versions exist for impact drivers but are not universal |
| Small cabinet hinges, drawer slides and hardware | Drill on a low clutch setting | The clutch stops the turn; Pro Tradecraft calls impact drivers a poor fit for small screws such as cabinet hardware |
| Furniture assembly with many 1-1/4 to 2-inch screws | Drill, or either tool | A clutch avoids stripped particleboard and crushed finishes |
| Deck boards, fence rails, 3-inch and longer wood screws | Impact driver | Impacts keep the screw turning against high resistance with less pressure on the handle |
| Lag screws and hex-head fasteners with socket adapter | Impact driver | The hex collet takes socket adapters; The Drive notes this makes the tool a compact impact wrench, though not as powerful as a dedicated one |
| Masonry anchors and holes in brick or concrete | Hammer drill with carbide masonry bits | Hammer action is the mode makers list for concrete (DeWalt, Makita) |
| Self-tapping and self-drilling metal screws | Follow the screw maker | Follow the screw maker’s installation instructions; a tool’s self-tapping mode does not replace them |
Can an impact driver drill holes?
It can, with the right bits. Pro Tradecraft reports that accessory makers now offer 1/4-inch hex-shank drill, spade and step bits, so an impact driver can drill as well as drive. The Drive adds that some users fit a keyed chuck with a 1/4-inch shank to hold standard drill bits. The limits are practical: every bit needs a 1/4-inch hex shank or an adapter, the impacting adds vibration in the handle, and there is no clutch.
The honest answer to “can one tool do both?” is that an impact driver can stand in for a drill for occasional small holes. A drill cannot stand in for an impact driver on large fasteners without strain on the motor and your wrist.
Impact-rated bits
Impact-rated bits are made for the repeated torque spikes of an impact driver, and makers market them with a torsion zone, a tuned section behind the tip meant to absorb peaks. Milwaukee’s Shockwave line says its Shockzone is “optimized for each tip type and length of driver bit” to absorb peak torque and prevent breaking, and that its Wear Guard tip protects fit. The company also claims “up to 50X life versus other impact driver bits,” a figure the product page does not support with a test method, so treat it as marketing.
The rule for buyers is simple and does not depend on a life multiplier. Use bits labelled for impact use in an impact driver; keep standard bits for a drill; and match the bit to the recess (Phillips, Torx, square) so it seats fully. A tip that fits the recess poorly is more likely to slip and round it out, regardless of the tool.
Technique: finishing the screw
On a drill/driver, start on a low clutch number and test on scrap of the same material. Raise the setting one step at a time until the screw seats flush. A setting that works in oak can bury the same screw in pine, so re-test when the material changes.
On an impact driver, start slowly so the bit seats, then increase speed. Choose the low-speed or precision mode if the tool has one: Milwaukee’s M12 FUEL 3453-20 lists four drive modes, including the self-tapping mode. Watch the screw head instead of counting hits. Stop when the head is flush, when the bit begins to cam out, or when the wood starts to split.
Where a drive must be tight to a specification, such as a structural connector, use the fastener maker’s stated method and a torque tool. A driver’s clutch number is not a calibrated torque reading.
Buying verdict
| Your situation | Buy | Add later |
|---|---|---|
| First tool, mixed home projects | Drill/driver with a 1/2-inch chuck and a clutch | Impact driver when screws grow longer |
| Frequent decks, fences, framing or repetitive long screws | Impact driver and drill/driver together | Hammer drill if you will drill concrete often |
| Occasional concrete or brick holes | Hammer drill | Impact driver for fastening |
| Tight spaces and overhead work | Compact impact driver | Drill for holes |
For occasional repairs, a drill plus a decent set of bits and a few clamps is the stronger first purchase. For a project with dozens of drill-and-drive connections, a two-tool kit saves the repeated bit changes: put a drill bit in one tool and a driving bit in the other. The two-tool kit is the better value only if both tools are the same battery platform and you have counted the battery, charger and bag; the bare tool listings such as Milwaukee’s “-20” models do not include them. The four-kit comparison on best power drills goes through specific kits.
When the tools arrive, a first project such as your first workbench uses both: a drill for pilot holes and a driver for the long structural screws. The workshop cost guide prices the tools in the context of a first project.
Sources
- Milwaukee: M12 FUEL 3403-22 drill/driver kit
- Milwaukee: M12 FUEL 3453-20 impact driver
- Milwaukee: M18 FUEL 2953-20 impact driver
- Milwaukee: M18 FUEL 2904-20 hammer drill/driver
- Milwaukee: Shockwave Impact Duty driver bit set
- Makita: XFD131 drill/driver
- Makita: XPH14Z hammer drill
- Makita: XDT20Z impact driver
- DeWalt: DCD1007WW1 hammer drill
- The Drive: what is an impact driver
- Pro Tradecraft: impact drivers, how they work and how to use them