Woodworking

Wood Selection Guide: Species, Grades, Moisture, Defects

By Hods Published · Updated

Choose the species by how the part will be used, then choose the grade by how much clear wood the part needs, then buy boards that are dry for where the piece will live. For indoor furniture and cabinets in most of the United States, the USDA Forest Products Laboratory recommends installing wood at an average of 8% moisture content (individual pieces 6 to 10%), which is lower than the 19% maximum that “dry” construction lumber is allowed to carry. Species decides hardness and movement: at 12% moisture, sugar maple resists denting with a side hardness of 1,450 lbf, nearly four times eastern white pine at 380 lbf. Grade decides how much of each board is usable. Inspection decides whether the specific boards in the rack will stay flat after you cut them.

The figures below come from the USDA Wood Handbook (General Technical Report FPL-GTR-282, 2021), the 2019 edition of the National Hardwood Lumber Association (NHLA) grading rules, and the American Softwood Lumber Standard (NIST PS 20-25).

Match the project to a species

ProjectSpecies worth shortlistingWhy, from the Wood Handbook
Painted shelves, cabinet boxes, trimYellow-poplar, eastern white pinePoplar is “comparatively uniform in texture,” is “stable after drying” and is listed for interior molding and cabinets; white pine is easy to work and glues readily
Visible furniture with a clear finishBlack cherry, black walnut, hard maple, red or white oak, white ashAll are listed for furniture; cherry is “very dimensionally stable after drying,” walnut is “well suited for natural finishes”
Surfaces that take impacts (bench tops, cutting boards, steps)Hard maple, ash, oak, hickoryThe top of the hardness range in the table below; hard maple is listed for cutting boards and gymnasium floors
Carving, practice joints, learning layoutBasswood, eastern white pineBoth are soft and light; basswood is “a favorite of wood carvers”
Outdoor, ground-contact or wet-exposure partsWestern redcedar, white oak heartwood (or treated stock rated for the exposure)Western redcedar heartwood is “very resistant to decay”; white oak heartwood has good decay resistance and is often specified for boat planking
Framing and the structure of a workshop benchDouglas-fir or Southern Pine in a stress gradeBoth are listed for building and construction; Southern Pine’s longleaf and slash species are “heavy, strong, stiff”

“Hardwood” and “softwood” are botanical terms. Hardwoods are angiosperms (flowering plants) and softwoods are conifers, and the handbook points out that “softwoods such as longleaf pine and Douglas-fir are typically harder than the hardwoods basswood and aspen” (USDA Wood Handbook, chapter 2). Look at the number, not the label.

Species table: hardness, density and movement

Hardness in the table is the handbook’s “side hardness,” measured with a modified Janka test: the load required to embed an 11.28 mm (0.444 in.) steel ball to half its diameter, here with the load perpendicular to the grain (Wood Handbook chapter 5). All values are for clear specimens at 12% moisture content. Tangential shrinkage is the percentage a flatsawn board’s width shrinks going from green to oven-dry (Wood Handbook chapter 4).

SpeciesSpecific gravity (12% MC)Side hardness, lbfFlatsawn shrinkage, green to oven-dryHandbook-listed uses
Western redcedar0.323505.0%Siding, decking, interior woodwork, sashes, doors
Eastern white pine0.353806.1%Interior woodwork, furniture, knotty paneling, doors
American basswood0.374109.3%Blinds, moldings, carving
Yellow-poplar0.425408.2%Furniture, interior molding, cabinets
Douglas-fir (coast)0.487107.6%Building and construction, millwork
Longleaf pine0.598707.5%Heavy, strong, stiff Southern Pine; construction lumber
Black cherry0.509507.1%Furniture, fine veneer, architectural woodwork
Red maple0.549508.2%Soft maple group: furniture, veneer, boxes, pallets
Black walnut0.551,0107.8%Furniture, cabinets, interior woodwork
Northern red oak0.631,2908.6%Flooring, furniture, millwork
White ash0.601,3207.8%Cabinets, furniture, flooring, millwork
White oak0.681,36010.5%Furniture, flooring, boat planking
Sugar maple (hard maple)0.631,4509.9%Flooring, furniture, cutting boards
Shagbark hickory0.721,88010.5%Tool handles, ladder rungs, athletic goods, furniture

Source for every row: handbook Tables 5-3b and 4-3. Species uses are paraphrased from chapter 2; where the handbook gives only a group (Southern Pine, soft maple) the row says so.

Three patterns matter when buying:

  • Hardness and density travel together. The three softest rows (350 to 410 lbf) are all at 0.38 specific gravity or lower, and every row at 1,290 lbf or more is at 0.60 or higher.
  • Hard is not the same as stable. White oak (10.5%) and sugar maple (9.9%) sit at the high end for tangential shrinkage, and eastern white pine (6.1%) and western redcedar (5.0%) at the low end. The handbook calls eastern white pine “high in stability” and western redcedar “very low” in shrinkage.
  • One name can cover several woods. The handbook notes that sawn red oak “cannot be separated by species on the basis of wood characteristics alone,” and “pine” or “cedar” in a bin may be any of several species. If hardness or decay resistance matters, ask for the species by its botanical or commercial group name.

Moisture content: the target is the room, not the rack

Wood gains and loses water until it reaches an equilibrium with the surrounding air. At 70°F, the handbook’s equilibrium table gives 6.2% moisture content at 30% relative humidity, 9.2% at 50% and 12.0% at 65% (Wood Handbook chapter 4, Table 4-2). A heated house in winter and a damp basement in August therefore produce a spread of several points in the same board.

The handbook’s installation targets (chapter 13, Table 13-2):

Use and regionAverageIndividual pieces
Interior woodwork, flooring, furniture, trim: most of the United States8%6 to 10%
Interior: dry southwestern areas6%4 to 9%
Interior: damp, warm coastal areas11%8 to 13%
Exterior siding, trim, sheathing: most areas12%9 to 14%

Retail construction lumber is not normally dried to these values. Under the American Softwood Lumber Standard, “dry” lumber under nominal 5 inches thick has a maximum moisture content of 19%, and the handbook notes that common grades of softwood boards and dimension lumber are not normally dried to the Table 13-2 values (NIST PS 20-25; Wood Handbook chapter 13). A grade stamp such as KD 15 generally means a 15% maximum. For furniture or trim, buy kiln-dried hardwood or acclimate the boards in the room where the piece will live.

How much a board moves

The handbook’s method for the 6 to 14% range multiplies a species coefficient by the width and the change in moisture content: change in dimension equals width × coefficient × (final MC − initial MC) (chapter 13, Equation 13-3 and Table 13-5). The coefficients below are the tangential values, which apply to the width of flatsawn boards. The widths are for an 8-inch board moving from 6% to 12% moisture, close to the equilibrium values Table 4-2 gives at 70°F for 30% and 65% relative humidity, roughly a heated room in winter against a humid one in summer:

SpeciesTangential coefficientWidth change, 8 in. board, 6% to 12% MC
Eastern white pine0.002120.10 in.
Western redcedar0.002340.11 in.
Black cherry0.002480.12 in.
Douglas-fir (coast)0.002670.13 in.
Black walnut0.002740.13 in.
Yellow-poplar0.002890.14 in.
Northern red oak0.003040.15 in.
Sugar maple0.003530.17 in.
White oak0.003760.18 in.

The calculation for white oak is 8 × 0.00376 × 6 = 0.18 in. A solid tabletop of white oak boards 8 inches wide therefore has to be fastened so it can move about three-sixteenths of an inch per board. The handbook adds that because commercial lumber is often not perfectly flatsawn or quartersawn, the method will probably overestimate width change, and chapter 4 puts the piece-to-piece variation in shrinkage at a coefficient of variation of about 15%, probably somewhat more in commercial lumber.

A board bought at the 19% dry limit and installed at 8% falls outside the 6 to 14% range of that formula. The handbook’s general shrinkage equation (Equation 4-9) assumes shrinkage begins at the fiber saturation point, 30% moisture content when the species value is not known, and is linear below that. For eastern white pine, with 6.1% tangential shrinkage, drying from 19% to 8% is 6.1% × (11 ÷ 30), about 2.2% of the width. On a 7-1/4 inch board, the dry width of a 1×8 under PS 20 Table 3, that is roughly 0.16 inch, a visible gap in a panel of several boards.

Checking moisture before you buy

Pin-type meters measure the conductance between two needles, and the handbook says the readings are “always subject to some uncertainty.” If the wood is wetter in the middle, drive the pins to about one-fifth to one-quarter of the board thickness to approximate the average. Rain-wetted surface fibers can raise a reading from uninsulated pins. The handbook’s guidance for lots is to test at least 10% of each item, and several pieces if the quantity is small. Using the room-matched target of 6 to 10% in the table above, a reading well above 10% on a board for indoor furniture is a reason to wait or to ask for drier stock.

Grades: how much clear wood you are buying

Hardwood grades measure the share of a board that can be cut into clear pieces. Softwood grades sort framing lumber by strength and finish lumber by the appearance of its best face, so the two systems read differently.

Hardwood grades (NHLA)

NHLA’s rules are the standard for hardwood sold for cutting into furniture and fabricated parts. The grade comes from the percentage of the board’s surface that can be cut into clear-face “cuttings” of a minimum size, with the reverse face sound (NHLA Rules, 2019 edition; Wood Handbook chapter 6, Table 6-1). The rule text quoted on this page is from that 2019 edition. As of November 2026, NHLA’s current rules book is the 2023 edition (NHLA Rules app), and every width, length, yield and cutting size in the table below also appears in the handbook’s 2021 Table 6-1.

GradeMinimum board widthRequired clear-face yieldMinimum cutting
FAS (Firsts and Seconds)6 in., lengths 8 to 16 ft83-1/3% (91-2/3% in some cases)4 in. × 5 ft or 3 in. × 7 ft
Selects4 in., lengths 6 to 16 ftFAS on the better face; reverse not below No. 1 Common4 in. × 5 ft or 3 in. × 7 ft
No. 1 Common3 in., lengths 4 to 16 ft66-2/3% to 75% for most sizes (100% on a 1 sq ft piece)4 in. × 2 ft or 3 in. × 3 ft
No. 2A Common3 in., lengths 4 to 16 ft50% to 66-2/3%3 in. × 2 ft

The rules also set limits on defects within each grade. FAS limits wane to half the length on either edge, requires 50% clear wood within one foot of each end, and admits warp and cup only if the entire board will still surface on both sides to standard thickness (13/16 inch for 4/4); a warped or cupped board 12 inches or wider can instead pass if ripping it yields two FAS pieces that meet the same test.

What the yield numbers cost you

The grade percentages are minimums, and they give a way to compare prices that the price tag does not. Suppose a tabletop needs 12.5 square feet of finished surface, which is 30 by 60 inches (1,800 sq in.) and needs 12.5 board feet of 4/4 stock if every inch were usable. At the grade minimums:

GradeMinimum yieldBoard feet to buy for 12.5 sq ft of clear parts
FAS83-1/3%15.0
No. 1 Common66-2/3%18.75

No. 1 Common beats FAS on cost only if its price per board foot is below 80% of FAS (15.0 ÷ 18.75). The yield is a minimum, boards often exceed it, and real yield also depends on how short the needed parts are: No. 1 Common cuttings can be as small as 4 inches by 2 feet, so short parts such as rails and legs suit it, while the 60-inch boards of the top suit FAS, whose minimum cutting is 4 inches by 5 feet or 3 inches by 7 feet.

Softwood grades

Softwood lumber sorts into categories with different rules (Wood Handbook chapter 6):

  • Dimension lumber (2×4 and wider), the framing stock in a retail yard, is graded for strength: Select Structural, No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3, with Construction, Standard, Utility and Stud grades for 2×4 sizes.
  • Boards (nominal 1-inch) sold as general construction lumber are usually No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3 Common.
  • Select lumber (finish boards, trim, paneling) is graded for appearance on one face: letter grades such as B&BTR, C Select and D Select, or names such as Superior, Prime and Choice, which are “not uniform across species and products.”
  • Factory or Shop grades, lumber bought to be cut up for sash, doors and other parts, are graded by cutting yield: Factory Select typically requires 70% cuttings clear on both sides, No. 1 Shop 50%, No. 2 Shop 33-1/3%.

The American Softwood Lumber Standard defines “grade marked” lumber as lumber that displays the official grading mark of an agency, so a stamp is how to confirm what you bought.

Inspect the boards before you pay

Walk the rack with the cut list. The handbook names six types of warp, which it defines as any deviation of a face or edge from flatness: bow, crook, twist, oval, diamond and cup. Warp comes from differential shrinkage between the radial, tangential and longitudinal directions as boards dry, or from growth stress, and irregular grain or juvenile wood makes it worse (Wood Handbook chapter 13). The definitions in the table follow the warp terms of the American Softwood Lumber Standard (PS 20-25) and the NHLA rules glossary.

DefectWhat it isHow to check
BowA flatwise curve from end to end: the face is curved along the lengthSight along the face from one end; PS 20 measures bow at its greatest distance from a straight line drawn end to end
CrookAn edgewise curve from end to end: the edge is curved along the length (NHLA calls it sidebend)Sight down the edge like a rifle barrel; NHLA stands the board on edge, measures the bend at its greatest distance from a straight line and deducts it from the width of a full-length cutting, so a 6-inch board with 1 inch of crook yields at most a 5-inch full-length piece
CupA flatwise curve across the width, from edge to edgeLay a straightedge across the width and measure the largest gap
TwistA curl or spiral along the length, so one corner rises off the plane of the other threeRest both edges of one end flat on a bench and measure how far an edge at the other end lifts (the PS 20 measure); the Wood Handbook figure labels this “rise of fourth corner”
End checks and splitsCracks that open at the end grainLook at both ends; NHLA’s FAS rule limits splits to a total length, in inches, of twice the board’s surface measure in feet (16 inches on a board of 8 square feet)
Surface checksLengthwise cracks in the face, most often on flatsawn boardsLook at the face under raking light
HoneycombInternal cracks formed in the late stages of kiln dryingNot visible on the surface; it may “go unnoticed until the lumber is machined,” so buy from a supplier that will take back defective stock
Loose knotsKnots that shrink free of the surrounding woodPress and tap each knot; the handbook notes that knots may loosen during drying
WaneBark or missing wood along an edgeCheck each edge; NHLA allows limited wane in each grade, and on the No. 1 Common face of a Select board the wane on both edges together cannot exceed one-third of the width

Mark the usable sections on the board with chalk against the cut list. A board with a defect at one end can still supply short parts, and crook narrows every full-length part by the depth of the curve.

For surfaced hardwood, the handbook’s Table 6-4 shows a rough 1-inch (4/4) board surfaced on two sides to 13/16 inch, and NHLA measures board footage before surfacing, so the price is on the full inch. Dry softwood dimensions are different again, and the nominal vs actual sizes chart lists all of them. Check the actual thickness against the finished part, since a cupped or twisted board must lose enough thickness to come flat.

Price by the board foot

A board foot is 144 cubic inches, a piece 12 inches wide, 12 inches long and 1 inch thick. NHLA rounds surface measure to the nearest whole square foot, calculates board feet by multiplying it by the standard thickness, counts any standard thickness under 1 inch as 1 inch, and measures surfaced lumber before surfacing (NHLA Rules 2019, paragraph 16). Hardwood thickness is expressed in quarters of an inch: 4/4 is 1 inch, 5/4 is 1-1/4 inches and 8/4 is 2 inches.

By volume, multiply thickness in inches × width in inches × length in feet and divide by 12: an 8-foot 4/4 board 8 inches wide is 1 × 8 × 8 ÷ 12 = 5.33 board feet. An NHLA tally rounds that board’s 5.33 square feet of surface measure to 5, so it counts as 5 board feet. The project material calculator works through board feet for a full purchase list, and the first workbench plan shows a cut list for a bench in dimensional lumber.

Compare quotes in a single unit: price per board foot, with grade and surfacing, and the board feet needed after the yield allowance above. A rough 4/4 board priced below a surfaced one is the cheaper buy only if you own a jointer and planer to flatten it, and you will lose thickness doing it.

Pre-purchase checklist

  1. Write the species or group, grade, thickness, and number of board feet for each part, including the yield allowance for the grade.
  2. Set the moisture target from the room: 6 to 10% for most indoor furniture in the United States, 12% average for exterior trim.
  3. Check the stamp or tag for grade and drying (S-DRY, KD 15, or a kiln-dried hardwood label).
  4. Meter several boards, not one, against that target.
  5. Sight every board for bow, crook, cup and twist; check both ends for splits and every knot for looseness.
  6. Lay the cut list over each board and confirm the longest and widest parts fit between defects.
  7. Stack the purchase flat on stickers in the room where it will be used before cutting, and recheck the meter reading.

Adhesive choice for the joints is covered in the wood glue comparison.

Sources